How the USDA Grading System Works for Steaks
The United States Department of Agriculture created a ranking system or quality grading system to rate the palatability of meat in regards to flavor, tenderness and juiciness. There are eight categories and they include factors such as firmness, texture, lean meat color, carcass maturity and amount and distribution of marbling within the lean meat.
Beef is graded when it is still in carcass form. A trained Agricultural Marketing Service meat grader inspects the whole carcass and measures it in terms of maturity and marbling. Marbling stands for the intramuscular fat in the beef and maturity is the estimated age of the cow at time of slaughter. The scores are combined to determine a particular cow’s final quality grade. The grade is then used for labeling purposes when the meat is sold.
Marbling is the tiny white flecks of fat that are scattered throughout the red lean part of the meat. The marbling keeps meat tender and juicy while it cooks and provides it with excellent flavor. Beef with high amounts of marbling typically earn a higher USDA quality grade.
The eight categories include prime, choice, select, standard, commercial, utility, cutter and canner.
Prime meat has the highest degree of marbling. This is the highest quality meat sold in the United States and it is usually found at high-end steakhouses.
Choice is a popular upscale grade of beef at restaurants and higher-end retailers. This grade actually has a fairly wide amount of variations with some cuts featuring almost a prime grade amount of marbling while other cuts have much less marbling, closer to Select.
Select grade features limited marbling and is less tender than Prime or Choice grade. This tends to be the most readily available grade of meat available in the United States.
Of the meats in the United States, only approximately two percent is USDA Prime. The majority of meat sold in U.S. grocery stores is Choice or Select.
Some individuals object to the USDA’s beef grades stating that they need to take tenderness into account when grading the beef. In response to this, in 1978 the American Angus Association created the Certified Angus Beef label to accompany the USDA quality grades. To be labeled as Certified Angus Beef, cattle must be 51 percent black Angus and meet the following criteria:
- Modest or higher degree of marbling
- Medium or fine marbling texture
- A USDA level "A" maturity
- 10 to 16 square-inch ribeye area
- Less than 1,000-pound hot carcass weight
- Less than 1-inch fat thickness
- Moderately thick or thicker muscling
- No hump on the neck exceeding 5 cm (2")
- Practically free of capillary rupture
- No dark cutting characteristics
View more articles from this columnist »
Bobby Fitzgerald is a 20 year restaurant veteran and passionate foodie. He grew up in Washington, D.C. and began working at the legendary Dancing Crab as a teenager. After studying culinary arts and food management at Johnson & Wales University, Bobby was a chef in Napa Valley and spent six years with Houston's Restaurants opening restaurants in five U.S. cities. In 1999 he started his company which today has locations in four states under The White Chocolate Grill and Cinzetti's Italian Market brands, serving 25,000 meals a week in from-scratch kitchens. All-the-while Bobby has dined in more restaurants then most food critics and creating fresh recipe ideas is a big part of his life. Bobby lives in Scottsdale, Arizona with his wife and three children and serves on the Board of Directors of The Arizona Restaurant Association as well as the Phoenix-Metro American Cancer Society. His current projects include Restaurants Against Cancer where Bobby is rallying the restaurant community to support camps for kids with cancer by donating the food and supplies needed to run the camps. Bobby is the author of "The Customer First Manager" available at Amazon.com.
- Column Archive
- Gluten-Free Dining is Here to Stay
- Restaurants For A Holiday Party
- Two Hours With One of America's Last Great Distillers
- Will Indian Food Make the Cut?
- Spring Vegetables
- Dining, Politics and Restaurants in America
- Low Calorie Menus
- Wine Part III: Virginia Wines
- Wine Part II: Kentucky Wines
- Wine Part I: Arizona Wines
- Fall Vegetables
- Wine Life Beyond California and New York
- Restaurant Week From Coast-to-Coast
- My Wife is Not a Guy
- Viognier Wine: A great way to expand your tastes
- Is Whiskey the next Vodka?
- Part II - Mexican Food and Mexican Restaurants
- Part I - Mexican Food and Mexican Restaurants
- Part II - Chinese Foods and Chinese Restaurants in America
- Part I - Chinese Foods and Chinese Restaurants in America
- Part IV - Pizza and Pizzerias in America
- Part III - Pizza and Pizzerias in America
- Part II - Pizza and Pizzerias in America
- Part I - Pizza and Pizzerias in America
- Food and Wine Pairing Tips
- Restaurant Review Sites - A comparison
- Quinoa: The Hot New Ingredient
- San Pellegrino Restaurant Rankings